The Fintech Index
219 companies rated 5 sectors 48 reports Last updated Nov 20, 2026
Tommy Nicholas
Alloy

Tommy Nicholas

Co-founder and chief executive

Why watch

He co-founded Alloy in 2015 to give banks and fintechs one system to orchestrate fraud, credit and compliance decisions.

Tommy Nicholas is co-founder and chief executive of Alloy, the identity and fraud prevention platform for banks and fintechs. He started it in 2015 with Laura Spiekerman and a high-school friend, Charles, who became chief technology officer, and nearly lost it several times before it found its market.

From ACH to Risk Decisions

He began with an idea around slow-settling ACH payments, and Spiekerman joined him from impact investing. The idea turned into a broader gap. There were plenty of fraud, anti-money-laundering and credit data products, but no system to pull them together into a decision about a customer. "There wasn't a system that was, you would expect to just buy, install, and then configure to actually make the underlying decisions," he said in a Future Nexus interview.

The Flatiron Argument

Early on he and Spiekerman had a heated argument outside the Flatiron Building in New York City. Afterward they wrote down frameworks for who owns which decisions, and the partnership held.

Four Demoralizing Years

Alloy did not raise a Series A until 2019. Many investors thought it would fail, and selling to banks meant far more compliance and security work than the founders expected. The company came close to shutting more than once. "The moment that things are actually pretty far into getting better, tends to be the moment people want to give up the most," he said on the Fintech Leaders podcast. The turn came with a large digital bank that had considered building its own version; that deal took nearly ten months to close.

Alloy Today

Alloy now draws on more than 200 data sources for more than 650 organisations, giving banks and fintechs one place to decide whom to onboard and which transactions to stop. He nearly gave up at the moment things were getting better, and he now tells other founders that is the moment to keep going.

Sources
  1. Fintech Leaders conversation: https://fintechleaders.substack.com/p/tommy-nicholas-ceoco-founder-of-alloy
  2. Future Nexus interview: https://cms.heyfuturenexus.com/tommy-nicholas-ceo-co-founder-of-alloy-on-fighting-fraud/
  3. Alloy: https://www.alloy.com/