The Fintech Index
219 companies rated 5 sectors 48 reports Last updated Nov 20, 2026

PCI-PAL vs Basis Theory: Features, Coverage and Pricing Compared (2026)

Updated November 10, 2026 · Reviewed by Benjamin Margolis

PCI-PAL and Basis Theory both keep card numbers out of a company's systems, but in different places. PCI-PAL captures card details on phone calls and chats, for live agents and AI bots. Basis Theory gives developers a vault to store card data and reuse it with several payment providers.

Our analysts compared the two on November 10, 2026, using each company's own product, pricing, and company pages and our full reviews of PCI-PAL and Basis Theory.

Choose PCI-PAL if

  • you take card payments by phone or chat
  • you want to shrink contact-center PCI DSS scope
  • you use AI voice or chat agents

Choose Basis Theory if

  • you store cards for online payments
  • you want to avoid lock-in to one processor
  • you have engineers to run the integration

PCI-PAL scores 70 and Basis Theory scores 80 in our ratings. PCI-PAL is for contact centers. Basis Theory is for developer teams that store card data.

Key Features Compared

PCI-PAL vs Basis Theory at a Glance, November 2026

FeaturePCI-PALBasis Theory
Ratings
Fintech Index score70 / 10080 / 100Higher score
Overview
What it isPCI-PAL provides software that lets contact centers take card payments across voice and digital channels while keeping card numbers away from agents, recordings, and internal systemsSan Francisco payment vault company whose developer platform tokenizes card and other sensitive data so merchants can reuse it across payment providers
Who uses itRetailers, insurers, healthcare payers, utilities, and contact-center software and AI-agent vendorsSoftware platforms, merchants, and fintechs, including Pinterest, Melio, and MoneyGram
Main productsSecure payment capture for phone and chat: Key to Pay, Click to Pay, and Speak to Pay, for live agents and AI botsCard and sensitive-data vault, tokenization, hosted Elements for collecting cards, and a Proxy that reshapes payloads for any provider
Where it operatesUK, North America, and other markets served through contact-center partnersGlobal; works with multiple payment providers
Products and features
Processes payments itself Passes payments to the client's processor Vault only; a processor is still needed
Pricing
How pricing worksSubscription pricing by quoteDeveloper plans, starting at $995 a month
Published prices Quote only Starter plan from $995 a monthPrice posted
Technology and compliance
Licenses and regulationKeeps card data out of the contact center, shrinking PCI DSS scopePCI Level 1, SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, and HIPAA; the Starter plan includes a PCI Attestation of Compliance
Developer tools Integrations for contact-center platforms and AI agents Developer-first API, hosted Elements, and Proxy
Integrations and partnersWorks with the client's existing card processor and contact-center softwareWorks with several payment providers; leads an Agentic Commerce Consortium of more than 20 companies
Onboarding and supportPartner-led deploymentsSelf-built integration by the client's engineers
Company
FoundedIncorporated 1999; trading on AIM as PCI-PAL since 20162020
HeadquartersIpswich, United Kingdom (group IR also lists a London address)San Francisco, California
OwnershipPublic (AIM: PCIP)Private, venture backed
FundingPublicly traded (AIM: PCIP)~$50M in total, including a $33M Series B in October 2025 led by Costanoa, with Stage 2 Capital, Moneta VC, Bessemer Venture Partners, and Kindred Ventures
Key leaderJames BarhamColin Luce
ScaleFY25 revenue of £22.48M, up 25%, with ARR of £19.26MMore than 40 full-time employees in October 2025

Fintech Index Scores Compared

We rate every company on eight criteria from 0 to 100, four tied to what buyers in its sector need and four shared by every company, and the rating is their average. PCI-PAL scores 70 and Basis Theory scores 80.

Criterion Scores Out of 100

PCI-PALBasis Theory
Sector criteria
Issuing / acceptance / initiation coverage7370
Developer and ops tooling7190
Compliance and security8792
Integrations and partners8578
Vendor criteria
Product depth and roadmap7782
Onboarding and support6776
Pricing transparency4678
Contract terms5870

Key Differences Between PCI-PAL and Basis Theory

Use Case

PCI-PAL's Key to Pay, Click to Pay, and Speak to Pay take payments on calls and chats without card numbers reaching agents. Basis Theory stores card data in a vault and passes it to providers through its Proxy.

Pricing

Basis Theory's Starter plan costs $995 a month. PCI-PAL prices its subscriptions by quote.

Company

PCI-PAL is publicly traded in London and reported FY25 revenue of £22.48M. Basis Theory was founded in 2020 and has raised ~$50M.

Pros and Cons

PCI-PAL

Pros

  • Takes contact-center systems out of PCI DSS scope
  • Works for live agents and AI voice and chat bots
  • Keeps the client's current processor
  • Recurring revenue grew in FY25

Cons

  • Not a vault for online checkout
  • No card acquiring
  • FY26 audited results were delayed

Basis Theory

Pros

  • Avoids lock-in to one payment processor
  • Strong compliance set: PCI Level 1, SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, and HIPAA
  • Published starting price of $995 a month
  • Highly rated developer tooling

Cons

  • Needs separate payment processors
  • Clients run their own integration
  • Not a phone or chat payment capture tool

Who Each Is Best For

PCI-PAL

The contact centre or contact-centre software vendor that needs agents and bots to take card payments without holding raw card data.

Basis Theory

A merchant or software platform with its own engineers that wants to hold card data in an independent PCI vault and send it to any payment provider.

Alternatives to PCI-PAL and Basis Theory

These companies, all reviewed and rated on The Fintech Index, cover some of the same ground as PCI-PAL and Basis Theory.

Other Card Issuing and Processing Companies

CompanyScoreBest forComparisons
Spreedly79Merchants that route card payments across several gatewaysPCI-PAL vs Spreedly
Spreedly vs Basis Theory
Finix78Software platforms that want to become payment facilitatorsNone yet

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Basis Theory work for phone payments?

It is built for developer vaulting, not contact-center capture. PCI-PAL handles phone and chat payments.

How much does Basis Theory cost?

Its Starter plan starts at $995 a month.

Sources
  1. The Fintech Index analysis of PCI-PAL and Basis Theory, conducted November 2026 (As of November 10, 2026)
  2. Basis Theory home page: https://basistheory.com/ (As of November 10, 2026)
  3. Basis Theory pricing: https://basistheory.com/pricing (As of November 10, 2026)
  4. Series B announcement: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/basis-theory-raises-33m-to-power-agentic-commerce-and-the-next-era-of-merchant-payments-302582581.html (As of November 10, 2026)
  5. Branch case study: https://blog.basistheory.com/case-studies/branch (As of November 10, 2026)
  6. Lithic, Fintech Layer Cake interview: https://www.lithic.com/blog/the-future-of-payments-is-agentic-and-tokenized-with-basis-theory-ceo-colin-luce-and-cto-james-armstead (As of November 10, 2026)